Eight opposition members were suspended from the Rajya Sabha this morning for the rest of the session over unprecedented chaos in the house during the passing of controversial farm bills on Sunday, but they refused to leave. The members, including Trinamool Congress's Derek O'Brien, Aam Aadmi Party (AAP)'s Sanjay singh, Congress's Rajeev Satav and CPM's KK Ragesh, were told they had displayed "unruly behavior especially with the Chair and gross disorderly conduct".
The refusal of the suspended members to leave the house caused multiple adjournments of the Rajya Sabha. The opposition said the members should have been given a chance to explain, but the Rajya Sabha said the decision was based on a government motion.
"I am naming Mr Derek O Brien. Please go out of the house," Rajya Sabha Chairman Mr Naidu said, as he named the suspended members. But none of the members budged.
Two of the government's three farm bills, which have led to massive protests by opposition parties and farmers, were passed on Sunday amid an uproar in the Rajya Sabha.
Sanjay Singh and Rajiv Satav climbed onto the Secretary General's table at the centre of the house, Derek O'Brien waved a rulebook in front of the Chairperson and tried to tear it up and some members pulled out mics at their seats. A few members also tore up copies of the bills.
At one point, marshals formed a wall between the Deputy Chairman and the protesting members. The bills, which were cleared in the Lok Sabha earlier, will now go to the President for sign-off before becoming law.
The opposition, which lacked the numbers to block legislation, had called for the farms bills to be sent to a select committee for review. They had also asked for the discussion to be extended to today. Harivansh Singh refused and allowed Union Agriculture Minister Narendra Singh Tomar to continue his reply before voting on the bills.
The row escalated when the opposition demanded physical voting but Harivansh Singh refused. Opposition members ran to the Chair, attempted to tear up the rule book and tried to snatch the Deputy Chairman's mic.
A voice vote took place amid slogans from the opposition. Opposition MPs sat on protest in the house, preventing the start of the Lok Sabha shift.
Nearly 50 members moved a no-confidence motion against Harivansh Singh, which was rejected today. "This does not end here," Derek O'Brien had said on Sunday, terming it a "murder of democracy".
"They cheated. They broke every rule in Parliament. It was a historic day. In the worst sense of the word. They cut RSTV feed so the country couldn't see. They censored RSTV. Don't spread propaganda. We have evidence," Derek O'Brien tweeted.
During the discussion on the bills, the government said the Farmers' Produce Trade and Commerce Bill and the Price Assurance and Farm Services Bill will bring major reforms in the lives of the farmers.
After the bills were passed, Prime Minister Narendra Modi tweeted: "For decades, the Indian farmer was bound by various constraints and bullied by middlemen. The bills passed by Parliament liberate the farmers from such adversities. These bills will add impetus to the efforts to double income of farmers and ensure greater prosperity for them."
The opposition alleges that the proposed laws will give power in the hands of corporates and farmers will be deprived of fair price for their produce.
The Developments :
# The House was adjourned for the fifth time till Tuesday.
# The Rajya Sabha standoff continued on Monday afternoon with opposition parties planning to meet President Ramnath Kovind in this regard.
# Union Minister Rajnath singh said, "What happened in Rajya Sabha today was saddening, unfortunate and shameful. It is the responsibility of the ruling side to enable discussions in the House but it is also the duty of the Opposition to maintain decorum. There are some political reasons behind every such decision. I don't want to comment on why did she take this decision."
# Union Minister Smriti Irani: The kind of attack on the Chair of Dy Chairman is saddening incident. Is it befitting to politics of this nation? Is it right to go & break mic at a chair on which not only Deputy Chairman but also the Vice President of the nation sits?
# "Suspension of the 8 MPs who fought to protect farmers' interests is unfortunate & reflective of this autocratic govt's mindset that doesn't respect democratic norms & principles. We won't bow down & we'll fight this fascist govt in Parliament & on the streets," said West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee.
# "Muting Of Democratic India’ continues: by initially silencing and later, suspending MPs in the Parliament & turning a blind eye to farmers’ concerns on the black agriculture laws. This ‘omniscient’ Govt’s endless arrogance has brought economic disaster for the entire country," Rahul Gandhi said in a tweet.